Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Pin to quick picksCloudified Holdings Limited Regulatory News (CHL)

Share Price Information for Cloudified Holdings Limited (CHL)

London Stock Exchange
Share Price is delayed by 15 minutes
Get Live Data
Share Price: 4.00
Bid: 3.00
Ask: 5.00
Change: 0.00 (0.00%)
Spread: 2.00 (66.667%)
Open: 4.00
High: 4.00
Low: 3.50
Prev. Close: 4.00
CHL Live PriceLast checked at -

Watchlists are a member only feature

Login to your account

Alerts are a premium feature

Login to your account

Negative decision by State Administrative Tribunal

3 Mar 2011 14:30

RNS Number : 2949C
Churchill Mining plc
03 March 2011
 



3 March 2011 CHL: AIM

 

CHURCHILL MINING PLC

("Churchill" or "the Company")

 

Negative decision by State Administrative Tribunal

 

 

·; The State Administrative Tribunal in Samarinda, East Kalimantan ruled on 3 March 2011 against Churchill Mining Plc ("Churchill" or "the Company") and its Indonesian partners, the Ridlatama Group ("Ridlatama") in regard to an attempt to cancel the EKCP licenses

·; The decision by the Samarinda Administrative Tribunal is not final and binding as a matter of law until after all appeal avenues have been exhausted

·; The proceedings before the Samarinda Administrative Tribunal do not constitute an action that will immediately affect the legal rights of the owners of the EKCP Licenses

 

Churchill Mining (AIM:CHL), announces that the State Administrative Tribunal in Samarinda, East Kalimantan has today ruled against Churchill Mining Plc ("Churchill" or "the Company") and its Indonesian partners, the Ridlatama Group ("Ridlatama").

 

Under the Indonesian legal system an Administrative Tribunal is supposed to rule strictly on matters of process as to whether bureaucrats, elected officials, and government institutions have observed procedural rules and regulations in making decisions. The proceedings before the Samarinda Administrative Tribunal do not constitute an action that will immediately affect the substantive rights of the owners of the EKCP Licenses and the decision by the Samarinda Administrative Tribunal is not final and binding as a matter of law until after all appeal avenues have been exhausted.

 

The Company strongly disagrees with the decision and is currently evaluating options to remedy the situation, including appeal to the State Administrative Tribunal in Jakarta. At no time during this process has Churchill considered the EKCP licenses cancelled or invalid.

 

Background to the State Administrative Tribunal

 

It was brought to the attention of the Company and Ridlatama in 2010 that the East Kutai Regent ("Regent" or "Bupati") had purported to have cancelled the four mining licenses that comprise the East Kutai Coal Project (EKCP).

 

Ridlatama and Churchill initiated the Administrative Tribunal in September 2010 in order to have the original cancellations officially expunged from the record, as they considered that the Bupati had violated a number of administrative protocols.

 

Ridlatama and Churchill requested that the review be held 'in camera' until the results were made public, although the Board took the decision on the 21 February to notify the market of the upcoming action, in-order to pre-empt potential speculation in the Indonesian press which could have been detrimental to the process.

 

The Administrative Tribunal did not however agree with Churchill's and Ridlatama's position and ruled that the Bupati's attempted revocation of the EKCP licenses did not defy any administrative regulations, a decision that Ridlatama and Churchill will appeal to the State Administrative Tribunal. Instead, the Tribunal cited an April 2010 letter from the Ministry of Forestry to the Regent advising the cancellation of Ridlatama and Churchill's licenses after receiving reports from residents that the Company had carried out mining activities leading to the damage of forestry areas.

 

Churchill strongly protests this decision and emphasizes that the Company and its partners have never done any mining at the EKCP site. Furthermore, Churchill points out that the communities around the EKCP site have never made such a complaint, a claim substantiated by a sworn Ministry of Forestry affidavit from the chief of the local Dayak cultural council (the traditional community's foremost authority on land issues) that affirmed that local land owners have found the EKCP partners to have never performed any illegal activities and to have acted responsibly at all times. This evidence was presented during the Administrative Tribunal proceedings. Finally, Ridlatama and Churchill note that the licenses that make up the EKCP, which were issued by the same Regent in 27 March 2009, lie outside forestry areas, and therefore are not subject to Ministry of Forestry oversight.

 

Validity of Licenses

 

Notwithstanding the decision of the Samarinda Administrative Tribunal, the validity of the EKCP Licences has been confirmed on at least two separate occasions:

 

t The BPK (an independent state agency tasked with the oversight and audit of state accounts and spatial data), and the East Kutai Police have upheld Ridlatama and Churchill's mining rights in relation to the EKCP Licences;

t During the Administrative Tribunal the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources' Head of Legal and Legislative Affairs gave expert testimony that the ministry continued to regard the EKCP partners' licenses as legally valid and enforceable, as no cancellation decree has ever been lodged with the ministry as is required by administrative protocol.

 

Next Steps

 

Though disappointed by the Administrative Tribunal's decision, Ridlatama and Churchill remain committed to remedying this unfortunate situation and will perform a serious and exhaustive evaluation of legal options.

 

The Administrative Tribunal has only concluded in the last couple of hours, and there is currently only a verbal report from the Company's counsel available. The Tribunal is expected to make available a written report of its findings in the coming weeks, and the Company will make a further announcement once the Board has reviewed this report in conjunction with its lawyers.

 

Restoration of trading on AIM in the Company's shares will take place at 15:00 today.

 

END

 

For further information, please contact:

 

Churchill Mining Plc

Managing Director - Paul G. Mazak

+62 81510539186 /

+ 62 21 39832398

+ 61 8 6382 3737

 

paul.mazak@churchillmining.com

 

Northland Capital Partners Limited

Shane Gallwey

Luke Cairns

+44(0)20 7492 4750

 

 

Tavistock Communications

Paul Youens /

Jos Simson

+44(0)20 7920 3150

 

 

pyouens@tavistock.co.uk

 

This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange
 
END
 
 
MSCJJMITMBTMBTB
Date   Source Headline
1st May 20249:03 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
30th Apr 20247:30 amRNSRestoration - Cloudified Holdings Limited
30th Apr 20247:00 amRNSInterim results
29th Apr 20248:30 amRNSNotice of Interim Result & Restoration of Trading
3rd Apr 20248:29 amRNSRetirement of Director
28th Mar 202411:42 amRNSUpdate
28th Mar 202411:37 amRNSFinal Results
12th Dec 20232:43 pmRNSCompletion of the Disposal & Directorate Changes
7th Jun 201712:00 pmRNSCancellation of AIM admission
16th May 20178:00 amRNSUpdate on Annulment Application
19th Apr 20179:00 amRNSFurther re Annulment Application
6th Apr 20179:00 amRNSBlock Listing Six Monthly Return
4th Apr 20178:15 amRNSFurther re Annulment Application and suspension
31st Mar 201710:00 amRNSHalf Yearly Report and Annulment Application
16th Mar 20178:00 amRNSBlock Listing Six Monthly Return
28th Feb 201711:45 amRNSUpdate
31st Jan 20178:23 amRNSUpdate
23rd Dec 20162:00 pmRNSUpdate
23rd Dec 20167:00 amRNSBlock Listing Six Monthly Return
7th Dec 20168:45 amRNSChurchill's claim against Indonesia struck out
6th Dec 20167:30 amRNSSuspension - Churchill Mining Plc
2nd Dec 20167:00 amRNSTiming of ICSID decision and temporary suspension
1st Dec 201611:52 amRNSResult of AGM
30th Nov 201611:00 amRNSTotal Voting Rights
30th Nov 20167:50 amRNSICSID Arbitration Update
29th Nov 20167:00 amRNSICSID Arbitration Update
16th Nov 20164:41 pmRNSSecond Price Monitoring Extn
16th Nov 20164:35 pmRNSPrice Monitoring Extension
16th Nov 20162:28 pmRNSICSID Arbitration Update
7th Nov 20167:40 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
7th Nov 20167:40 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
3rd Nov 201610:41 amRNSDirector Shareholding
2nd Nov 20168:00 amRNSPosting of Annual Report and AGM Notice
19th Oct 20162:24 pmRNSFinal Results
11th Oct 20168:57 amRNSBlock Listing Six Monthly Return
6th Oct 20167:00 amRNSBlock Listing Six Monthly Return
15th Sep 20168:00 amRNSBlock listing six monthly return
12th Sep 201612:37 pmRNSICSID Arbitration Update
12th Aug 20169:12 amRNSDirector/PDMR Shareholding
29th Jul 20167:00 amRNSTotal Voting Rights
1st Jul 20163:00 pmRNSIssue of Shares
23rd Jun 20168:00 amRNSBlock listing six monthly return
21st Jun 20169:53 amRNSFurther re forgery dismissal application timing
17th Jun 201612:03 pmRNSUpdate on forgery dismissal application
6th May 20169:30 amRNSResult of General Meeting
5th May 20161:30 pmRNSUpdate on Indonesia's default in ICSID proceedings
29th Apr 201610:00 amRNSTotal Voting Rights
20th Apr 201612:39 pmRNSUpdate on Indonesia's default in ICSID proceedings
14th Apr 20164:40 pmRNSSecond Price Monitoring Extn
14th Apr 20164:35 pmRNSPrice Monitoring Extension

Due to London Stock Exchange licensing terms, we stipulate that you must be a private investor. We apologise for the inconvenience.

To access our Live RNS you must confirm you are a private investor by using the button below.

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.