RE: Trekmadone2 Dec 2023 20:55
Hi Patryk,
Completely understand where you are coming from. However, one can interpret metrics in a variety of ways. Take 3 takeovers for example.
One could say that the fundamentals and discount and outlook is so strong that approaches were made but batted away by great defensive work by the SHG shareholders and investors!
And regarding a low ball, Eric will not be short of changed when he leaves so watch out for another bid!
Similarly I could pair numbers for EDV against PAF and tell ya what even though I donât hold EDV, they would beat PAF on many financials!
But I havenât bought EDV, not saying anything wrong with EDV ergo not saying anything wrong with SHG. Itâs just my individual view based on my interpretation and investment âneedsâ.
Hopefully, I made that clear when I said
â⌠nor necessarily would the others be better or worse, PAF definitely scratched my itch!â
But I did say I do not see some âstartupsâ as investible. However, for transparency, I have traded many successfully, or rather a more accurate descriptor is⌠âluckily!!!â
What I do respect though is someone like yourself that has rationalised several positions and reached their own conclusions!
That is worth more than the hundreds of âÂŁ10 a next weekâ posts that ones sees on these BBâs which would be fine if those posts came with some qualification!!
Still I note you only sold half of your SHG and are therefore ostensibly purporting if you should flip the rest? Or you would have sold 100%?
If it helps, like you, I hold both and would add to PAF over SHG atm.
However, I would be cognisant of fx on both. I would not sell my SHG to buy more PAF.
I respect some investors may have one or the other in which case one has to watch spread, currency, divi outlook etc and sticking with either position may be best as we donât know the future!
If you are looking in and want an opinion on whether to buy SHG or PAF for an instant upside gold playâŚ.
Iâd say buy EDV!âŚlol!
If you wanna trade, Iâd say use FRES, I mean I am so lucky there already!!
If ya wanna tuck away small cap âsafeâ gold plays with risk and upside potential Iâd say 60/40 PAF/SHG.
But if you are a new buyer for a one and âmid riskâ play Iâd say PAF.
No idea if that helps!
Usual caveats
Trek