True sale for SMEs15 Sep 2022 13:24
The FRC who have seen the accounting advice given to SYME made SYME publicly state that they don’t think SYME’s true sale accounting works in their annual report.
Yet bullish investors who are clearly not accountants try and make arguments for why they think it works using examples which rely on different fact patterns and often wrong accounting standards.
As to IFRS for SMEs I suspect that paragraph 23.A.3 a of the SME standard on revenue which states that
The seller recognises revenue when the buyer takes title, provided
a) it is probable that a delivery will be made
Given SYMEs SPVs never take delivery of inventory , true sale looks a dead duck.
Finally SYMEs business model has two elements
Front end sourcing customers and having systems which can administer client inventory.
Back end securing financing and constructing securitisation vehicles
Taulia owned by SAP which are software experts already does the former at some scale.
It is backed by JP Morgan who raise finance and perform securitisations at scale regularly.
How hard would it be for Taulia to replicate SYME supposedly unique business model?