REFLECTION, PERSPECTIVE, SHARE PRICE & DEAL26 Jan 2023 10:14
Uncertainty & inactivity kills confidence. We seem to have embraced a degree of confirmation bias that a lowish offer acceptable to the BoD & CA will emerge, which SHs should agree reasonable in all the circumstances. Whereas I don't know what will transpire, reflection often helps. Consider these SPs:-
09.03.22 12.34p (12 month high)
25.03.22 9.5p
13.04.22 11.14p
25.01.23 8.05p
When SP retraced from 12.34p to 9p-11p March 22, consensus was it was it’s correct range - NO outcry that it overvalued HUR. Bonds remained payable In July 22. P6 needed to pump. Upon bond repayment a sea change was visible - $60 mill free cash remained. Feb 23’s imminent offload will see +$140 mill cash. Any deal legalities would take 2 months so cash would be $160-$165 mill ie 6.8p p.sh. So, essentially, what has changed, for good or bad, March 22 - Feb 23?
1. Free cash increased from zero to +$140 mill – net 5.8p p.share (positive)
2. Plan (P8) abandoned (negative)
It fails my sniff test that 12 mths problem free P6 5.8p p.share production profits essentially equates in value to the loss of Plan P8 (or similar, which I believe reversible via new management), and renders fair value now 9p-11p ie: SP March 22 when HUR had zero free cash & bond debt existed. I believe it unwise to too hastily discounted that CA may have:-
a. Lost patience Sept 22 after P8 abandonment collapsed deal wherefrom CA planned to return 50p p.share to it's SHs.
b. Agreed with Saba & other main SHs that, given 2 of it’s other asset companies could not monetize before end 2024, a new timeline of end 2024 for HUR monetization.
c. Viewed the current SP, when compared to March 2022’s & HUR’s now materially improved position, as being so far removed from fair value so as to require new executives to restore fair value.
d. In short, in Sept/Oct 22 fundamentally changed mindset and timeline, commenced talks with Albion, and thereafter called the currently cancelled sacking EGM.
If so, the likely unforeseen will have been HUR introducing an early Jan bid deadline, effectively extended to 6 Feb by CA. If CA has indeed reset it’s target higher, a bid would either need to meet those higher expectations, or CA now lower them. Given so many variables, if CA have had a fundamental rest, for a bid to succeed needs considerable luck.
I repeat I have no idea what will transpire. Just that my gut has been complaining for a while about confirmation bias that a deal will be done at a certain SP level. Put another way, what would all have said in March 22 if asked about a 10-12p deal in Feb 23 with +$140 mill free cash banked ($160-$165 mill free cash - 6.8p.p.sh at deal’s legal completion)? Would you have considered such a deal reasonable?