Idle speculation2 Dec 2023 22:53
At this point I believe the share price and MCAP are irrelevant to the financial deal being negotiated. The deal is all about the cornerstones and their investment. They will want as much from the deal as they can. So with the assumption that we don’t go into administration or that there is no takeover and a full equity agreement then it’s all about percentages. So to maximise that they can only go for a split of 30:30:30:10. The 10% being the rest of us. If there is no retail offering then that means there are a finite number of new shares that can be created. Current shares in issue 270 million. (Not including all share not converted, as this is just an illustration). 51% is currently the cornerstones. So 49% (the rest of us) of 270 million is 132 million. If this is then 10% then the new total amount of shares that could be in issue is 1,320 million. 1,320 - 270 = 1,050 million new shares. That is I believe is the max number that could be issued. At the minimum of the 20p issue limit the that would raise £210 million. Given that A1 has in itself an NAV of approximately £1 billion say 80% of that the share price would be £800 million divided by 1,320 million which is 60p.
The second option is La Mancha increase to 30% with Glencore and Orion increasing proportionally with no retail offer. Simplistically it would mean La Mancha doubling their current number of shares from 62 million to 124 million. The total shares in issue would need to be increased to 410 million shares. Total new shares issued 140 million. To raise £210 million the raise would need to be at £1.50. Given that A1 has in itself an NAV of approximately £1 billion say 80% of that the share price would be £800 million divided by 410 million which is £1.95.
This is intended to show two scenarios where a finite number of shares would be issued and the consequences of that. In both cases La Mancha ends up with 30% of the company the maximum without a takeover.
In the first La Mancha would have to buy 334 million new shares at 20p, £66.8 million. Glencore 348 million, £69.6 million. Orion 368 million, £73.6 million. Here retail are only left with 10%.
In the second La Mancha would have to buy 62 million new shares at £1.50, £93 million. Glencore 48 million, £72 million. Orion 28 million, £42 million. Here retail are left with 32%.
So what best for each company? I’m sure that each will win at our expense. I’m sure someone could work out what each has invested so far and hence what they would loose if no deal or what the gain with a deal. I’m sure that each will win at our expense. I’m sure the mine will be financed and built. I’m sure that each will win at our expense. But, I’m hoping that at least we still get some scraps. If we get the first I’ll be disappointed but resigned to mitigate a bit of the lose, 60p a share with a 4 to 5 pence dividend. Not too good for the long term holders, but a good punt for a newbie.