RE: Nickel Prices Face Bearish Production Forecasts8 Feb 2023 14:01
Why are we arguing over analyst predictions when exactly zero of them predicted the current price 12 months ago?
https://knoema.com/ydolvrc/nickel-price-forecasts-long-term-2021-to-2030-data-and-charts
'The World Bank, in its commodity forecast report, estimated that nickel prices will fall to a low of $16,000 per metric ton in 2022, but they expect the average spot price for nickel will grow slightly further after the correction, reaching $18,000 per metric ton by the end of the year.'
December 2021 https://investingnews.com/daily/resource-investing/base-metals-investing/nickel-investing/nickel-outlook-price-gains/
'Sharing his thoughts with INN, Andrew Mitchell, Wood Mackenzie's head of nickel research, said that, broadly speaking, the nickel market performed as expected. His firm started the year with a 2021 price forecast of US$19,400, with prices now likely to average around US$18,500 for the year....
Looking over to prices, Wood Mackenzie expects nickel prices to remain strong at about US$19,800 in nominal dollar terms. Similarly, CRU expects prices to remain at high levels.'
I particularly like this one:
'On 1 December 2022, ANZ Research forecasted nickel to average $25,130 a tonne in 2022, falling to $22,575 in 2023 and dropping further to $19,225 in 2024.' Making a full year prediction with only one month of the year left is hardly valuable insight.
I thought Wood Mac, ANZ, and the World Bank would be enough to illustrate the point. There are dozens more. What they all share is getting the market wrong by a long way on pretty much every forecast variable for 2022. Expecting the same people to do better in 2023 is silly.
Macro factors that could swing in multiple directions will enormously influence the price for the next three years. These people making predictions are not stupid, it is just very very hard to predict:
1. The war in Ukraine is dragging on more than anyone expected. Sanctions on Russia may well eventually affect base metals as well as oil exports, and also affect machinery maintenance by Norilsk. Even if the war ended tomorrow, its after effects will go on for years.
2. Global recesssion. Just as everyone gets their head around there being a future global recession we may in fact already be emerging out of it. Energy prices have retreated which were the primary driving factor. As oil and gas prices fall the knock on effect for industrial energy production and transports will start to reduce inflation, with a lag time of 6 months. If we are indeed over the worst then global recovery will boost demand cycles for all minerals towards the end of 2023.
3. China, Indonesia, Philippines. Export bans, ability to ramp up, environmental credentials, sabre rattling over Taiwan, and even balloongate mean no one in the west wants to solely depend on China for supplies anymore.
4. LME instability and dwindling stocks. SMM is currently trading at a hefty premium to LME after the debacle of the spring,