RE: Financing26 Sep 2018 19:27
Thank you for that faramog.
So basically you think they have under delivered and are less than open about things, in fact verging on the misleading. Its a point of view I respect but can't fully concur with but I haven't been with RED for 2.5 years although prior to investing I kept coming over to see what progress they were making now and then.
The rest of your post refers to GEN3 and the supply of vanadium. I have seen no data on GEN3 but RED says that it compares favourably to competition. I don't think RED's offering to customers is just about GEN3 though. As I understand it, some of the additional staff make up a finance procurement section which packages the whole thing up in a business model for each individual customer's requirement. Its a rounded package which offers customers a one stop solution for their energy storage programme. Correct me if I'm wrong in this. Thats a very attractive offering which I think will be a winner. Under those circumstances it doesn't really matter if GEN3 is the best. It just needs to fulfil the storage needs of the model and, in this respect, it appears to be successful. I understand that the German order is not an order until the finance is in place and the ink is dry but to get as far as they have is demonstration to me that RED's business model is working. Anglian has certainly bought in to it and the guy in charge of renewables there. I can remember his name, is no mug. The next 3-6 months will indicative of RED's longer term prospects IMHO
As far as Vanadium is concerned I have no deep understanding of that market or supply capacity but it is usually the case that when a resource goes up in price investment comes in and the price stabilises somewhat and some circumstances declines. I have no idea if this will happen with Vanadium but if it gets too high then vanadium products will be priced out of the market and prices will fall. Schoolboy stuff I know. This will effect other Vanadium users as well. The question is are flow machines better enough against others in the market to make the increases in prices that will follow to still attract customers? The other question is can saving in cost in other areas compensate for the increased cost of Vanadium? Certainly economies of scale usually help in this direction. So, although the price Vanadium will be a problem, can RED still gain market share? My opinion is they can but its a risk factor that we have to monitor.
Summing up, the development of GEN3 was behind expectations, which is by no means uncommon with this type of product developments, and its not clear if it is the best of class but does it ultimately matter. RED's business plan and model seems to be working but there is a risk in the price and maybe the supply of Vanadium.
Its a risky business investing so you look at things from different angles, make your mind and take appropriate action. My action was to invest but it might be different for others. Thats called the Market.