RE: Dcu29 Mar 2024 22:11
Hello all,
After yesterday’s DCU settlement, 5.20837p received (of which 5.19 came from OUR money, I like to remind everyone), 7.29163 remains to come; quite a way to reach 12.5p !
Regardless if you are in profit or seriously under water this was a deal made from a very demonic place, even hell pales in comparison. Put simply we have been fleeced !
I am firmly with senseman on this, and really commiserate on his and others’ losses. I have been there a few times and know how it feels
As for the tax treatment of this hellish scheme I stand by my posts of 22 Mar 2024 14:05 under RE: March DCU Payment – key information and 22 Mar 2024 16:25 under RE: Tax treatment of DCU payments
In my view, nimrod99 post of 23 Mar 2024 18:53 under DCU (started on 23 Feb 2023): -
“As to receipts ending up in a trading account I shall regard them as a return of the capital that will reduce to zero in 2026 which I shall neither report or regard as taxable”
is misguided on several level.
Firstly, there could not be a return of capital as we no longer own the company.
Secondly, I am not saying it applies under PRAX DCUs, the tax treatment regarding returns of capital has been settled very recently by the Court of Appeal in Alex Beard (a Glencore former executive) – v – HMRC
Whereas Glencore did not pay dividends but instead implemented a return of capital twice yearly, HMRC position was upheld, namely that such payments should be treated as income, i.e., as dividends, as opposed to Capital Gain – meaning a tax of 33.75% or 39.35% depending of tax rate on income over £50,270/125,140, as oppose to a flat 20% (https://uk.news.yahoo.com/glencores-ex-head-oil-loses-131802249.html)
Enjoy all Easter 🐸