Crucial weeks ahead9 Aug 2020 12:30
As we reach a crucial period I believe it might be worthwhile to try and place a value on MTL right now had the stock been trading on the open market.
Obviously the debt situation makes it hard to deliver a like for like peer group comparison but I would like to try and demonstrate that the upside for the major shareholders equity positions will far outweigh the money they have loaned the company and the price they paid to buy the bank debt.
So let us assume, based on a number of assumptions and historic data, the major shareholders have injected actual cash of £50m into MTL (this ignores the penal interest on the mezzanine debt)
Also bear in mind that operational performance at the mine was improving and historically the company has been hamstrung by lack of funding which has hindered both operations and exploration.
The nearest comparison I can find via the market is Anglo Asian Mining (LSE:AAZ) they are producing circa 80,000 oz of gold a year at a cost of around $700oz - a target MTL could attain and possibly exceed under normal operation performance.
Anglo Asian hit £1.70p this week which values them around £175m - it is not unreasonable for MTL to attain such a market value or even exceed it. Gold is forecast to go higher still remember.
It seems obvious that the major shareholders will benefit far more from their equity positions than the money they have injected historically, surely they must recognise this. It is essential for them to reach agreement on the outstanding matters ASAP, losing the Stock Exchange listing will be costly, exceptionally time consuming and drawn out if they wish to have it restored - many examples show 12-18 months is the norm.
The equity 'value' based on Candy's current stake (based on a EV of £125m) would be circa £80m and Edwards would be £35m, the loans could be recovered from operational cash-flow, this assumes MTL would reach a £175m market valuation upon lifting the suspension or around 8p a share.
I believe the market would value MTL in that range, there is also the potential for the company to be bought out, this would further enhance the major shareholders financial position should bid speculation arrive.
In conclusion, in my view, it is obvious the equity value of the major shareholders stakes is far greater than the actual money they have put in to support the company, they have a great CEO plus a decent on ground team, what is there not to like.
One final aspect, recent brokers have started to upgrade gold producers market valuation targets, I believe at Anglo Asian the new target in IRO £220m and not the £175m I have used here.
If they do not reach an agreement it is, in my considered opinion, just plain stupid given the current dynamics of the sector.