RE: Current Position14 Oct 2022 22:20
I don't see how the production of fuel was a f*** up of any kind, especially from QFI's perspective.
Q38: "We have 2 full-sized MMUs, how did we end up delaying the Morocco project by a whole quarter because of an inability to manufacture MSAR? Not a good look re: project and risk management."
A38: "The 2 full-size MMUs are not ideal to supply smaller batches of 10-60 tons product. Our new smaller unit of 5tph needed to be commissioned and was ideal for trial production. The delays experienced to Morocco MSAR supply were regrettably down to both delayed deliveries of equipment components for this unit and then unforeseen manpower limitations at our supplier during the Summer. Lessons have been learned by the project team to ensure this doesn't happen again."
So, let's analyse that one piece at a time:
The 5tph was delayed due to issues outside of QFI's control:
1) Component delays can be an issue with anything these days. Component suppliers will promise dates with the best of intentions to deliver, and then miss those dates due to issues that have arisen in the meantime with their own suppliers. Semiconductor supplies are still an issue, sometimes there will be a batch released which fills some outstanding orders, and then supplies will go quiet again until the next batch is released, it's really hit and miss. These days, getting components delivered on schedule is a bit of a luxury.
2) Manpower limitations at our supplier. They could have had a covid outbreak, or any number of other issues, but it's nobody's fault, you can't blame the supplier or QFI for a staff shortage at the supplier, especially when you have no idea what caused it.
Some claimed QFI should have used the other MMU's to make the fuel.
"The 2 full-size MMUs are not ideal to supply smaller batches of 10-60 tons product. Our new smaller unit of 5tph needed to be commissioned and was ideal for trial production."
Clearly QFI made a management decision to stick with the 5tph based on the equipment capability. This is not a f*** up, it is an intelligent and well thought out choice based on the options available:
1) Use an MMU that was not suitable for the job
2) Wait for the 5tpd and do the job properly