RE: Third Avenue Value Fund12 Aug 2025 10:48
"Hi GOCPI. Just wondering what your take on the latest rns. How do you think a valuation can be met in these distressed times?"
Hello Longfell - you've also confirmed that the valuation price for MSQ was £170m and their EBITDA then was circa £20m. Their EBITDA% is/was pretty similar to S4s.
The ownership structure for MSQ is 59.6% OEP, 15.6% LDC (PE firm which majority owned MSQ prior to OEP buying 60%) and MSQ management owning 24.8%. This is per their latest end-Feb 2024 annual reports. Post acquisition date (June 2023) revenues to end Feb were £181m, but the annual numbers since March 2023 were £240m. Taking just the £181m revenues, US contributed £44m, which would've doubled since October 2024 acquisition of a NY creative company. THey're now a circa £275m to £300m revenue company, I'd suggest, well under half our net revenue numbers at circa £750m.
OEP paid decent money for that 60% MSQ deal at that £170m valuation 2 years ago - a circa 8.5x EBITDA multiple if that £20m EBITDA number is correct. A quick glance at the latest EBITDA number from the recent report shows a similar EBITDA % to revenues - about 11 to 12%.
S4's stockmarket valuation is insanely low, simply put. We're at a circa 1.5x valuation on that typical Acquisition related metric. To get on an equal footing should a merger need to happen with MSQ, then S4 valuation on a relative basis with MSQ should ramp up dramatically from what the insanely silly UK stock market is currently valuing us at. That could be 3x or 4x from these levels to even get close to a level-playing field.
I'll try to take a closer look at their numbers and see what more I can find.