Polar Landscape!28 Oct 2021 14:57
Analysis of the Trading Update for Q3 2021 seems to have polarised into two camps. Those who think these are outstanding/phenomenal results, and those who are disenchanted with the distributions from the corporate treasure chest. For me, the highest ever CFFO excluding working capital of $17.5 billion, puts me firmly in the first camp and speaks for itself. Surely setting a record in financial performance is good. Give or take the impacts of a Hurricane Ida, which is part of the wallpaper in a global commodities business, and for me this is a shout from the rooftops level of performance. Although Shell has rightly recognised that it would be politically insensitive & damaging to inflame the fossil fuel agenda at COP 26 further.
There are a hundred permutations of how Shell could distribute this. Amongst these, Net debt has decreased by $8.2 billion to $57.5 billion in Q3 2021. Essentially they were in the enviable position of choosing how much profit they made, and where, in the 3rd Quarter. You cannot please all of the investors all of the time, but the commitment to distribute the proceeds from the Permian Basin sale as a Special Dividend looks like a great start. Will it bolster the share price - yes, it certainly will.
I have felt for some time now that Shell has been clearing the decks for an enormous merger or acquisition. Shell has sold off peripheral, non-core, high capital intensity, relatively low-return businesses. Streamlined it's balance sheet, cut costs on a massive scale, harnessed cash, reduced debt & also ensured that it is geared-up to recover from the COVID 19 impacts very fast.
The rumour mill mentioning a tie-up with BHP has credence. Shell has always had an integrated vertical structure business model. With fossil fuels they (simplistically) explore and extract, process, distribute and sell their products. With renewables they have been dabbling around with wind farms, photo-voltaic panels, batteries etc etc. But, for me they will want to apply the same business model as they have for fossil fuels. I am convinced that they want to acquire a world-player to extract and mine the lithium, rare earth metals etc that will drive the green revolution. Watch this space.
If anyone is unconvinced of Shell's value. Think of why Daniel Loeb is convinced with Third Point! It is unlikely that he is simply interested in creating value by dividing the fossil fuels from the renewables business, the pot of gold is breaking up and selling the whole company bit by bit. Check out what happened to the John Laing Group, when the value of its constituent parts exceeded its capitalisation. Check out what will happen to William Morrison Supermarkets - of course it has not been taken over because the freehold value of its properties exceeds its capitalisation!
Financial performance & results are very different animals to pure distribution!