RE: Ian King Live - Sky News - Channel 23312 Apr 2023 17:40
Good question Johnnyrh. My personal thesis is that the SP is heavily discounting the outcome, which is why I have re-invested recently having, very luckily, sold at 1850p shortly pre-Muddy Waters (the Founders had sold a bit at c. 1400p I think and that slightly unnerved me at the time). If memory serves the SP got up to 850p within the last year, before the certainty of a YPF win. I recall that Peel Hunt were valuing the SP at c. 1100 at roughly the same time. I think the Preska judgment answers the Muddy Waters and SEC Fair Value methodology questions very definitively. They seem to have built a good book of business ex-YPF, so I think almost no value recognised for YPF. The one risk for me is if the SEC issue turns much more malign. From what Mr Bogart very extensively explained of the situation (I listened to both recent investor calls) that would be a great surprise.
Purely my own take on the opportunity. As ever PDYOR of course.