TIME FOR A RERATING16 Dec 2013 08:58
Last year we saw a late push in December taking this to a year high close on New Year's eve of 125p. Clearly we have seen significant upside since then, although not that much above the FTSE 250 index (I know Xch is no longer in there but it seems a far better fit than the Small Cap and beside I am hoping to see it back in next year). Most of what I wrote about on 07 Nov, when the share price was 131p, has come to pass, and we are now at 160p which is where, in the opening line of that post, I had said I thought we should have been then. With this also being the current price to which analyst consensus has now moved it may therefore seem illogical to want to revise my previous view for next year. I think however that we are starting to see a fundamental rerating of Xch and as such could see a p/e being applied far closer to Capita's, which is 17 times earnings estimates, (see article referred to on the HL website in my post of 22 Nov) rather than the discounted one that has been applied since the bloodbath of Feb 11 when David Andrews resigned, and £100M+ of goodwill was written down. Given how cautious our 2 accountants at the helm are and given that they nudged expectations up at Q3 I would expect further good news at the full year. If you combine a p/e uplift with full year earnings ahead of even post Q3 consensus, then we could be in for significant upside to the valuation of Xch perhaps to as much as 250p. Now this is all very good but I don't think the markets are ready to take Xch there yet (although this is a share which in it's heyday was north of 300p and on a a higher p/e than Capita) but I could see around 200p in the next twelve months. The other possibility of course is that, now that the US quagmire has been tidied up (not sure you tidy quagmires but hopefully the point is understood) and Xch has simplified its accounting and commercial models, Xch becomes a takeover target for one of the big boys, motivated either by its juicy procurement division (3rd biggest player in the world) or the way it has managed to hard wire itself into the back office of Lloyds of London. If the takeover were to happen (and I would put the odds at no more than 20%) then the 250p could be seen next year.