RE: collatorised loans/margin lending stocks26 Feb 2022 19:21
If you follow this type of stock, like me you probably think the large NAV discount has got to correct at some point, a large equity gain to be had; my experience in reality is that it doesn't materialise, and certainly not in a short time period. I don't think thats because of an ignorance of such, of shareholders, more an acknowledgement, a security to deliver the ongoing yield.
a lot is to do with tax, look at where all these sort of companies are domiciled (low/tax free jurisdictions), and that the professional (already rich ) people/orginazations at the heart, with large shareholdings want dividend income rather than growth capital gains, as generally taxed lower. I'll give an example.
I'm invested in LIV a small cap in this sphere; noticed the considerable discount to NAV, noticed it's considerable consistent cash/profit generation, and it's at that time large 7% dividend. I also noticed its considerably large single (owner) holding. People have differing views on a large controlling ownership of any Co - some think it shows aligned interests, some (like me), worry that if at a considerable NAV discount, they can low ball the Co private at profit at small investors expense. Despite my reservations, i took the view that that major interest would at some point want to realise the NAV difference, in the most tax efficient way to him - dividends, and as a shareholder i would benefit too.
For 2-3 years I was around 15% underwater equity cost wise, the divy making it equallish; the last dividend shot this into the profitsphere for me (i look for 10% pa growth across growth/income stocks), as the major shareholder did what i suspected - took money out the most efficient tax way possible, dividends; yes the NAV discount has fallen, it is still seriously high, and it barely took out the cash sitting at hand, forgetting its ongoing margin (profit) generation. These sort of investments aren't meant for the private investor, they are very much set up to provide tax efficient divvys rather than less onerous capital gains taxes for those already beyond allowances, high net worth people, hence i don't think you will ever see notable capital gain/SP appreciation. My views, and this area is risky if you don't research them, but i ave and happy to ride their coat tails. In summary, in this sphere, i don't think you will EVER see the NAV discount realised at one point in time, so no quick buck, i do think these discounts will be realised slowly but surely for the patient by way of yield. Sorry if i'm going on!