Conjecture11 Oct 2020 12:00
Note post title - that's what this is, though it is based on many years of investment activity and a reasonable knowledge of both the mechanics and mentality of the city.
When a share price in which I'm invested move sharply I like to know why, 'cos almost without exception there are underlying reasons, so here goes.
The rights issue has proved problematic for RR , two of the main underwriter GS and MS were so concerned that they'd be left holding the baby that they scaled down their commitment, BNP HSBC and others stepped in .The consequence of that is that the RI was priced at bargain basement levels to be sure that it "got away" , underwriters drive a very hard bargain when they know they might be on the hook to sweep up hundreds of millions of unwanted shares. RR had no choice but to "over egg" the issue to be absolutely sure of substantial take up.
The wider city recognise this and now see the chance for a quick buck , if you're a hedge fund or investment bank , or a longer term return if you're an investment manager. Hence sharp buying pressure this week by those intending to take up all of the accompanying rights
All this suggests that the RI will be fully subscribed and may well be heavily over- subscribed ie many may seek excess shares.
That presents RR with another problem, they can't legally increase the amount of shares on offer, nor would they as they know this is a give-away price , so they have to structure any excess allocation ,and remember there will be those both II and PI who see this as a chance to get out at a profit/small loss and /or will not take up their allocation . What RR want is a stable share register of long-term holders so do they fill excess requests from the bottom up (ie small holders first ) or top down hoping that some of the bigger players will sit tight for an eventual re-rate of the SP. They will be taking soundings to see how the wind is blowing.
So as a PI what to do?
I intend take up my allocation and bid for excess, unless, depending on the pattern of holding RNS's over the next few weeks , the majority of the buyers are hedgies looking for a quick turn. I will be more likely to commit if they are predominantly asset managers , buying on their "own book" ie insurance companies, the Vanguards or Blackrocks...., a strategic player, turn around investors etc...
But as ever DYOR and that includes shooting down my thesis , if you have other facts , opinions ,..... I have no problem with constructive criticism, so fire away.