RE: SBS17 May 2020 15:39
Esduk
PF kindly confirmed that the 59% was based on H2 2019 soft start numbers and not the 2019 annual throughput.
In respect of my stab at a number I made two assumptions ;
A- Keyguard hourly rate of £14.00 pr hr - IMO won’t be far away from the number we charge.
B - That we get paid the same fee for all crates - This is an unknown but highly unlikely.
The information we were provided simply notes a number of crates scanned at 309k and we have an amount of cash from RR to attribute to that volume which comes in at the £2.00.
I do agree with you that our actual number (per laden)crate may well be north of this , however the average per container throughput will be lower based on the following thinking;
In 2018 the consistent number I have found for TEMA throughput is 836k crates.
That year the cumulative number for laden Import ( 503k ) / Export ( 119k ) crates was 612k which suggests 224k crates were a mixture of empties & crates imported in to Tema for coastal distribution to regional ports.
In respect of the former , empty crates in countries with such a large trade imbalance as Ghana is a pain in the rear for the shippers as the back loads can be at a discount of up to 70% on some routes , which I why I suspect the Maersks of this world would want to pay a heavily discounted number for port fees in respect of empty crates.
In respect of the latter consider this senario -
A Maersk container gets loaded at Singapore ( Bollore controlled ) , and shipped and off loaded at Tema ( Bollore / Maersk JV controlled) , then reloaded for local coastal distribution to say Lagos , Lomo or Abidjan , ( all Bollore Controlled ) as a final destination.
Do we think that
A - Maersk would pay Bollore four times to scan the same container ?
Or
B - The crate gets scanned at Singapore , barcoded to notify other ports it has been scanned and has not left any secure zone during transit , therefore no further scanning required ?
As simple as it sounds It’s a complicated subject .
We may well be getting paid close to Mikes £6.33 number for “laden” crates , however other handling may incur no scanning or will be heavily subsidised which will bring the average £ take down against throughput.
I have read that shipping lines occasionally load entire container ships with empties - if we had one of these ships in Q4 it would clearly of brought our take down .................AIMHO and no doubt as clear as mud .....(o: