RE: BMN24 May 2018 21:25
@Bolgas I appreciate that you are talking about V205 prices, whilst I in the main focus on BMN's main product which is effectively FeV. V205 prices currently sit at around $14 per lb mid price.So for them to touch the high single digits, we are talking about a effective 33% reduction from here.
If I applied the same calculation to FeV then we are talking about a drop from $64.25 to around $43.
To place that in context, it's important to analyse what the price correction as it currently stands.
FeV prices (mid) peaked on 28th March peak at $71.50 FeV prices and are off approx 10% at $64.25.
V205 prices having peaked at $16.4 per lb on 6th April are currently trading at $14.2, which is a 13.4% drop.
It has taken 3 months for prices to recede that far. With Q2 2 months old, we have 4 more months of trading before your expected rise would kick in, a rise I assume you believe will be driven by the new Chinese rebar Regs in November. In terms of V205 we are talking about a drop of just $2.20 per lb in 3 months.
If we look back at the last time that prices dropped following the rise into Q3 2017, then we see a fall from a peak of $48 on 11th Sept to $34.50 on 20th Oct. That's a 28% drop in 6 weeks. Now when we look closey at the reasoning behind the price drop in September 2017, we do find that as you have indicated, it was an end to the environmental inspections in the main Chinese vanadium producing regions that led to additional supply coming on line and thus a reduction in prices.
However, this time we are coming from a much higher pricing level and yet prices are falling with far more reluctance. Furthermore, there is no clear supply trigger. There are no environmental inspections that have come to an end. Infact there are no indications in the information I have seen, that demonstrate one single change on the supply side and this is backed up by the shallowness of the decline in prices.
If the demand/supply balance had been tilted like it was in Sept, then the price fall would be far sharper because traders would be scrambling far more to offload stock bought at what are near record pricing levels. As it is the message is unfaltering, that supply remains tight and it is a softening of demand that is easing prices.
However, with the world economy and in particular China showing no signs of a major decline in its growth this year, the drop off in demand cannot hold and nor can the steel mills attempt to counter the market demand/supply dynamics.
So for me not only is the infomation from the main news sources strongly indicating that we are simply waiting for the buyers to step back in, but also the price reaction too. It is clear the traders are confident because they aren't dumping their material, they are simply waiting because the buyers can't hold out forever, and for me that time is almost upon us.