Doomsday Scenario Planning12 Sep 2023 21:38
Clearly today's 15% share price drop surprised a number of folks with a "leap" (shuffle?) from 49.5% to 51.9% LTV being the new catastrophe. Others revealed how they'd cleverly disposed of RGL before today's results. Meanwhile we didn't achieve the predicted 60% covenant breach catastrophe, but we now face a new peril - "dangerously high" levels of LTV and "savage cuts". Let's try to work through the level of danger we (well those that remain) face.
I've run a number of scenarios to ascertain what level of danger in 6 scenarios and what the impact would be:
Using £752,226,000 Current Value of Property and £390,462,000 net debt (i.e. the 30th June numbers)
Scenario 1 - If RGL can dispose at a 5% discount to NAV how much must it sell to reduce LTV to 40%
Answer: £94.3m of property
Scenario 2 - If RGL can dispose at a 10% discount to NAV how much must it sell to reduce LTV to 40%
Answer: £99.5m of property
Scenario 3 - If RGL can dispose at a 20% discount to NAV how much must it sell to reduce LTV to 40%
Answer: £112m of property
Scenario 4 - If RGL disposes of £30m of property at a 19% discount to NAV, but its ENTIRE portfolio also drops by 19%. What is the resultant LTV?
ANSWER: 60.09% - convenant breach
Scenario 5 - If RGL disposes of £60m of property at a 19% discount to NAV, what market drop would lead to a LTV >60%
ANSWER: A 40% drop from here.
(Got to consider a positive scenario too)
Scenario 6 - How about if the NAV increased by 10% or 20%, how much property would I then need to sell to get to 40% LTV?
Answer: Just £59.5m, or with 20% just £29.4m
Conclusion: When you look at this proportionately, you'd have to have a H2 result **3 times worse** than H1 in terms of NAV drop to breach 60%. Meanwhile there's plenty of evidence of stablisation shared on this BB - and in the realised prices achieved on offices sold, so show me other REITs selling off property at a 19% discount to their June valuation?
Nevertheless there's criticism you can put on my models - what about rent roll and covering admin costs, what about dividends you're not factoring in those, but even if I did factor those in the dial ain't going to move 3X to suit the negative narrative.
So the next question to ponder is a 15% drop today an overreaction and therefore an opportunity for buyers? The reduced dividend at today's market price is 12.6% yield. At what point does this become too cheap and just not dangerous enough?
GLA