Pensana31 Aug 2022 22:23
Taking the true reserve as 1/3 of indicated resource and 1/2 of measured resource at LJ that is 85,000 tonnes of NdPr, the company is now valued at $2,000 per tonne of NdPr using likely conversion metrics to reserves. This equates to a gold miner being valued at $40 an ounce in their reserves or a resource calibrated equivalent in a fairly stable African state. It values COOLA at nothing, REOs as zero, Saltend development as it stands at zero, all inferred resources at zero and only includes material above the 0.2% cut off and no material beyond the LJ weathered zone and equates no cash in the bank despite a recent $10M placing. A significant proportion of shares, some at 120p have been purchased above the current Pensana share price by AWF so the largest shareholder is heading towards a negative valued holding.
Pensana, Peak, Rainbow, MKA and Lynas have all moved in a similar pattern since 1 January 2022. Lynas only deviated upwards on 26 July. Peak data stopped on the Hargreaves and Lansdowne comparison chart a few weeks ago and was a considerable under performer to that time. RBWR has fared slightly better than MKA and Pensana, but its more a chemical processor and so more comparable to a Saltend only facility than a full mining enterprise. For that matter NEO was also 50% down until the recent news last week.
China market sources have indicated today that exports of NdPr oxides and REOs have declined by 60% thus far in 2022 and I suppose are inferring this to be the real reason for the price drop in the markets. The automobile sector has reduced ordering significant supplies. This appears to fit in with other commodities that have also declined in price as the manufacturing industry has the double challenge of higher energy prices and consumers for their products facing inflationary stress from a range of sources.
The single positive point I will make is that although increasing interest rates may be lowering commodity prices at the present time, it is setting up a much higher price rise later on as company stocks and warehouses are heading to record lows thus recreating the inflationary spike in commodities that arose after prolonged lockdowns from Covid19 with supply disruptions. The only thing that would stop such a second inflationary surge in my opinion is moving a recession into a much prolonged depression with long term demand destruction that included widespread sovereign debt defaults which I hope does not happen.
All the best Tony