RE: Advice on averaging up23 Sep 2025 23:11
Interesting crossroads you’re at. BP and RR are very different beasts — BP is a mature cash-cow with dividends doing the heavy lifting, whereas Rolls is very much a growth story where capital appreciation is the main driver.
If you believe in RR’s trajectory (margin expansion, deleveraging, SMRs, defence, UltraFan optionality), then yes, it could comfortably outpace BP over the next 12 months. But the flip side is risk: BP offers ballast and income, RR offers torque and momentum.
Personally, I wouldn’t frame it as “sell all and switch” but rather balance the two depending on what you want your portfolio to deliver. If you want growth, RR is the lever. If you wish to yield and energy exposure, BP has its place.
In short, I wouldn’t advise putting all your oil barrels into one jet engine, but trimming BP to reweight into RR for the growth leg makes sense if that aligns with your risk appetite.