RE: TSX peer group 4x CNR's valuation5 Nov 2017 21:19
Wondergoals, if we agree that the current resource is roughly similar (CNR's is slightly better but not a great deal), then the only difference (and we'll ignore Dugbe and Cora Gold for the moment, as the market is anyway) is about four years and �100 million in market cap.
Now let's work a scenario through for CNR, discounting the unlikely takeout (I hear booing and hissing!):
4 years worth of working capital to get it through the permits, BFS and build ~�12 million.
$120 million for the plant - let's go with 80% debt ($96 million), being generous, which leaves $24 million (�18.5 million) in equity raise.
So, best case scenario to production is about �30 million of additional equity being issued. Add that to the recent share price of ~�30 million and you get �60 million of equity.
So, for that, assuming you traverse a similar path to HUM you will approximately only double the value of your current investment 1 month out from first pour with an MCAP of �130 million. And you will have to wait FOUR YEARS for that! At that point CNR would have a debt of $96 million. HUM has only $60 million and is on a trajectory to have $15 million in the bank at first gold pour as they are coming in under budget.
Now, do you seriously think HUM's potential has been realised? I don't, barely scratched the surface and most of the risk has been removed. Talk about a truly excellent risk/reward play.
CNR on the other hand has all of the risks associated with getting permitted, financed and built (delays, additional costs, unforseen problems, yadiya).
Of course, the above analysis didn't include the drilling that CNR are doing. If they can bring that into the resource and improve the NPV and economics then that will improve the payback. But then of course drilling, analysis and resource upgrades use up additional funds and they take a substantial amount of time.
HUM have gone hammer and tong at the heart of it - target the open pit, get it built and THEN prove up the rest of the resource - potential already unlocked you say? How about $70 million annual profit which they can use to hammer out the infill drilling at Yanfo, and buy in other satellite projects like AGG for an absolute steal.