My take13 Dec 2021 09:14
This message board doesn’t really allow us to differentiate between peoples time horizons for investing/trading. A market needs contrarian views and participants with different investment horizons. That’s what makes it a market. Is one set of participants right and one wrong? No. They are just targeting different outcomes on different timeframes.
Kuvari, Marshall Wace, citadel etc are hedge funds. They are called fast money. They care about momentum, they care about market equilibrium, they care about NEXT set of earnings and the short term factors influencing a stock.
T Rowe, blackrock, Norges are REAL MONEY. They are investors. They care about fundamentals. They care about company strategy, management, wider industrty dynamics and market positions over multiple years. They care about what the next 1-5 years earnings will be and will give the company a fundamental valuation.
With regards to boohoo, it’s clear on this board we have both short term technical momentum traders like Marshall targeting a few % here and there for kicks and thrills and the norges who will look at fundamentals and think “I can buy that here and in 12-24 months it will probably double”.
I have a family away from my interest in stocks. I also have a full time job and attached to that line of work some compliance restrictions around my minimum holding period for investments. For that reason I am a forced fundamental longer term investor. For me, buying boohoo at 160p and it going to 140p in January makes no difference. I don’t mark myself to market daily and 1 month is not my investment horizon. I could not sell even if it tripled due to compliance issues I have. All that matters for me is my conviction that come January 2023 and beyond that the stock will be meaningfully higher than it is now. And Yes i do have that conviction. So why has it been selling off and why may that continue?
1. Esg. The fast money knows many real money institutional holders are forced sellers for ESG reasons. Even if they love the boohoo story they simply have to sell. And when sellers > buyers the SP goes down.
2. Recent operating weakness driven by short term logistics issues, cost inflation from commodities.
3. FX. Weak sterling will hurt the margins of U.K. retail who source in dollars from Asia and Turkey etc.
But the good news is all the above are transitory, and 100% of the time, all the time, do normalise. Maybe it takes 1-2 quarters but it always happens. During the tough times the weaker business (especially in retail) with bad market and industry position, maybe too much debt do fold, no online presence etc fold or restructure. Think top shop as prime recent example. The better operators with strong get products and balance sheets ALWAYS come out of these periods strong and more importantly BIGGER.