Frustrated placees10 Mar 2022 12:29
I wonder if some of the negative, critical chat on here (and on Twitter) comes from people who took part in the placing last July. I didn't take any, although I did talk to Ben over that weekend about it. Ben worked really hard ringing and emailing around private investors he'd been in contact with. He didn't want the placing only to go to the usual suspects who take (and flip) lots of placings. He wanted to give loyal PI a chance to be involved. That takes up his time to do that.
You'll recall the placing was at 5.5p, with warrants at 8.5p. At the time, that was a good price. The share price had risen steadily from the 2p/3p level up to just over 6p. So a 10%-ish discount offered a good entry. Not long after, the price dropped back to the 5.5p to 6p range, and has spent quite a while below the 5.5p placing level.
Because the placing was taken by lots of smaller holders, that's (a) more, (b) less-experienced at placings - holders who took a large chunk at 5.5p. I don't know what timescale they expected a return on that investment. Quite possibly people were looking for 8-10p over the following few months. It would be quite understandable for there to be a clamour from people wishing they'd bought in the market at 5p instead.
A few things to say to people in this position.
1. By investing in the primary capital market in this way, you helped KAV to be the well-funded entity it is today. If everyone had held off, hoping to build that kind of size in the secondary market, they wouldn't have the resources to pursue this drilling / survey programme.
2. You still have the warrants. If we hit a big discovery, I expect the share price to be and stay in double-figures. Yes, you could have had a lower entry. But, if this works out, the warrants mean your profits will be better than they would have been if you'd just bought at 5p. [Say it hits 12p. For every share you took in the placing at 5.5p you get 6.5p profit from the share and 3.5p from each warrant. Warrants were 1-1. So that's 10p profit per share. If you bought at 5p in the secondary market, you'd only have got 7p profit per share. Even if the price only hits 10p, you get 4.5p + 1.5p = 6p profit, compared to 5p]
3. It so happens that the placing was at the optimum time. Yes, short-term, that means you're underwater. But, long-term, that means they raised the maximum working capital for the minimum dilution, which keeps down that all important "shares in issue" that has been discussed here today. (I don't believe Ben did the placing expecting the price then to drop; he respects rather than uses private investors, it seems to me.)
At the end of the day, this is an early-stage explorer, and any investment here is a risk. However and at whatever level you invest, if this fails you lose out. But by investing at placing time, you've put your risk to work to help this succeed, and your share of the profits will be the greater for it.