RE: This Train is leaving the station31 Aug 2025 15:48
I've had time to mull over the delayed results. They obviously wanted to wait until they could add in some good news about the new trading facility.
If we cut out the waffle that auditors put in to try and make things look more optimistic, we are left with essentially this: A significant widening of full year losses with falling revenue. Last year pre-tax losses of £264million (previous year £160m loss), sales down by nearly a fifth, market capitalisation down to only £200million, and an intention to sell the loss making brand PLT. In a nutshell, the company is contracting in order to become leaner and more efficient. That's their stance (excuse) essentially rather like Asos'. It is disconcerting to see that the 'net assets' of the company has plunged to £3.9million from a previous £280million figure.
Concerning the new borrowing facility. Not attractive at 7.3% above base and unnecessary given a cheaper option. £175m facility, up from £125m, gives them breathing space. But the devil may be in the detail. Everywhere detailing this is the phrase ''up to £175m'' which to me indicates that maximum level will only be allowed subject to them keeping within the covenants agreed upon. Bearing in mind the recent difficulties in them delaying refunds, one wonders if they are already into that £extra £50m lifeline.
Regarding PLT. Let's take a step back. In I think about 2017 Boohoo (Mahmud Kamini), bought 66% of PLT from brothers Umar & Adam Kamani for £3.3million (£3,300,000). In 2020 Boohoo, primarily under the control of Mahmud Kamani, bought the remaining 34% for a staggering £269.8million. How that happened is beyond me. People's speculation on here about the valuation of PLT are wide of the mark in my view. Here we have a distressed company, with part of it PLT, losing significant money. A forced seller of a loss making brand is not going get many generous offers. In my opinion, the 34% purchase in 2020 effectively took money out of the entire company structures into private family hands. Nothing new there.
The day after the results, Carol Kane, founder and Group Executive Director of Debs , purchased 6.9 million shares at 14.50 pence each, totalling approximately £1 million, This transaction increased her stake to 2%. Let's hope it is because she has faith in the new strategy rather than propping up the share price. She could have been averaging down of course (a risky personal strategy), given her previous relatively recent purchases at over 30p !!
The Debenhams brand, now central to the turnaround, has shown modest growth, with a 34% year-over-year increase in gross merchandise value and an adjusted EBITDA of £25 million. Yet, this progress is overshadowed by the broader challenges of declining core brand sales and competition from the likes of Shein etc but also, in my view, the continuing presence of the Kamani family. MA may well just sit in the wings for the time being and be a pain in the neck for Mahmud at the A