RE: Divided7 Oct 2023 09:50
Dr P.
Yes, fully agree.
The case did relate to the divi's, as a consequence of the manner in which he had acquired the shares. As such, as a sop to forego salary.
I also think HL is being very cautious.
Whole heartedly agree that it is an situation between the individual and HMRC.
For me, the fact that Glen account for it as a capital reduction wins the day, and i have and will continue to treat it in a similar way, and thereby capital repayment and not dividend.
Glencore is, as we know, held in a different territory, hence no stamp duty on share purchase. So, for me, the fact Glencore's tax is treated differently, draws a parallel to the treatment of shareholders receipts.
Reflect the payments from Glencore, as you see fit, to HMRC.