RE: Not good1 Oct 2024 14:34
Apologies for typos. My keyboard is splaying up and I didn't proof read previous post.
I was thinking about FX hedge a lot. Many posters here say it is stupid not to hedge. I dont think it is that easy.
Say SAVE want to hedge the entire $100mm worth of NGN cash. Say they put on the hedge start of 2024 at 900 USDNGN.
**** Unhedged: $56.25mm
01/01/2024 $100mm * 900 USDNGN FX = NGN 90bn
06/30/2024 NGN 90bn are now worth $56.25mm (1600 USDNGN FX spot)
You record a drop in cash balance in $ terms (although the NGN 90bn still sit on your balance sheet)
**** Hedged: $75mm
01/01/2024 $100mm * 900 USDNGN FX spot = NGN 90bn
Put on a 6m hedge, ie. sell NGN 90bn, buy USD 6m forward at 1200
06/30/2024 NGN 90bn are now worth $56.25mm (1600 USDNGN FX) at the spot rate
Your FX hedge matures and you settle the pnl in $: [ NGN 90bn / 1200 ] - [NGN 90bn / 1600 ] = $18.75mm
You record a drop in cash balance in $ terms as in the unhedged case,
You record a hedge gain of $18.75mm
I am disregarding NGN interest as this cancels out in both examples.
You notice the forward rate is much higher than spot because of the interest rate differential USD vs. NGN.
This is all well and good ex post.
However if NGN didnt move, ie. spot 06/30/2024 is trading around 900, we would be $25mm worse off with the hedge (that is the hedge pnl we need to pay out to the broker).
Similarly, if NGN strengthened to 700 by 06/30/2024, the unhedged version would again be $25mm worse off.
Here is a scenario analysis, using above example, but varying NGN spot rate on 06/30/2024:
Summary:
With the hedge you are guaranteed -$25mm.
Without the hedge your pnl can be -43.7 to +28.5mm [ie. 18mm worse off to 53mm better off vs. the hedged version]
It all depends on your outlook on NGN.
NGN
Spot $Cash Cash p&l Hedge p&l Total p&l
700 128,571,429 28,571,429 (53,571,429) (25,000,000)
800 112,500,000 12,500,000 (37,500,000) (25,000,000)
900 100,000,000 0 (25,000,000) (25,000,000)
1,000 90,000,000 (10,000,000) (15,000,000) (25,000,000)
1,200 75,000,000 (25,000,000) 0 (25,000,000)
1,400 64,285,714 (35,714,286) 10,714,286 (25,000,000)
1,600 56,250,000 (43,750,000) 18,750,000 (25,000,000)