RE: Msi4 Sep 2025 12:10
Hi JL & RM...I, too have been looking at valuation. Because the properties are all part of the ongoing concern for each division, I don't think you can just put a value on them unless they are surplus to requirements (very unlikely) and the operations can be amalgamated into the other sites. The usual approach of corporate bankers is to use EV/sales and/or EV/EBITDA multiples. For an "un-trendy" industrial business EV/sales ratios usually fall in the range 0.5x to 2.0x; and for EV/EBITDA, the usual range is 5.0x to 12.0x dependent on growth rate and cost savings potential for the acquiror(s).
Before applying these multiples to the three non-defence businesses, it should be noted that we do not know the split of depreciation between the businesses, so have to use EBIT rather than EBITDA; also, profitability is somewhat depressed in these businesses, so EV calculations based on EBIT come out low. Applying 1 x prospective sales gives you an EV of £31.5m; applying 10x EBIT gives you £12.7m, with the average being £22.1m.
The market cap of MSI is £199m, take off the cash £27m), leaves an EV of £172m. Take off £22m potential disposal proceeds gives an EV for defence of £150m, or 1.5x sales and 6.9x EBIT. Using Cohort as a comparator, CHRT is trading on 1.1x EV/sales and 10.4x EV/adj.EBIT.
Hope this helps.