Update from JPM post 30/6 Nav & writedown28 Jul 2023 12:06
Everything else being equal, the writedown of Anuvia would reduce
our live NAVe by 2.3% or $14.0m from $620m to $606m or from $12.63 to $12.34 per
share. But today we are also making another change to our NAV to remove our
performance fee accrual. RSE pays its GP a performance fee of 20% of gross realised
profits subject to it meeting a portfolio level cost benchmark, which, at 31/12/22, was in
deficit by $95m. Footnotes in the quarterly NAV statements indicate the size of the
potential accrued fee which is not accrued until the portfolio cost level benchmark is met.
Our live NAVe includes our estimate of the potential performance fees, which today is
$29.8m, but, with RSE now significantly further away from the cost level benchmark test,
we are now removing that performance fee accrual from our live NAV. After adding back
the $29.8m, we were including for the performance fee accrual, our live NAV would be
$12.95 per share or 1,003pps. But we are also updating to include the latest share
buybacks for the period since 31/3/23, which results in our live NAVe increasing by a
further 33 cents to $13.28ps/1030pps (ie including the Anuvia writedown, buybacks and
the removal of our performance fee accrual). So despite the bad news, our live NAVe is
actually up overall by 5.1% as a result of our overall changes. Our 30/6/23 NAVe on the
same basis would be $12.98ps/1,022pps.
• Based on the current share price of 530p (@09:00), the headline discount to our live NAVe
is 48.6% but deducting net cash and the listed holdings at NAV, the implied discount on
the remaining unlisted assets is 123%. This is one of the widest discounts for any listed
private equity company we cover. While the Anuvia writedown is disappointing news for
RSE shareholders and a set back for RSE in its strategic transition towards
decarbonisation investments, a >100% implied discount on the unlisted assets implies the
market already applies no value to those investments at the current share price. We are
Overweight.