RE: MCAP £280m12 Apr 2021 23:35
Bluelight wrote: "My take is dhsc didn't take all the volume they were contractually committed to, and ncyt are taking legal action to basically take or pay, but we are all unclear."
If that is the correct explanation, then Novacyt would probably have a strong case from a contractual point of view. Perhaps there is a lot of money potentially at stake in this dispute.
However, is it wise for Novacyt to refuse to make a short-term monetary concession to their biggest customer, when they are hoping to have a continuing long-term relationship with the NHS in the supply of diagnostic tools to hospitals? Furthermore the announcement of the dispute in the latest RNS has caused an immediate 40% drop in Novacyt's share price which equates to a £200 million drop in its market capitalisation. That might turn out to be a temporary drop if the share price should recover, but a lot of shareholders will have sold at the latest price because they can't cope with the volatility, in which case for them the loss in their portfolios becomes permanent. Is that worthwhile in return for, say, a once-off £20 million revenue gain should the dispute eventually be resolved in Novacyt's favour? Perhaps the company wasn't expecting such a massive reaction to the RNS, but it does make me question its CEO's judgement in this instance.