RE: Dbw20 Dec 2021 11:45
"My biggest fear with this stock is that BHP and/or NCM ensure the boardroom is stacked with 'their' people "
Sharketmare...once again I ask the question...
By what process can that happen?
There are only three ways even ONE BHP Director could get on Board...
1 If they take up their place by right. If they were going to 'stack' the Board don't you think they would have done that by now?
2 The Board appointment process:
The Nominations Committee propose(s) a candidate (s)
That Committee now consists of: Kevin O'Kane (Chair), Liam Twigger, Maria Amparo, Nick Mather
OK so to be fair KOK spent 14 years at BHP, but MAA is truly independent; Liam Twigger publicly called out BHP and Nick isn't going to support a BHP candidate.
So even if KOK tried to push one he would be massively overruled, even if it got to the Board itself.
3 BHP could put up a candidate at the next AGM if there was a vacancy and trust they would get elected, but as I just said, why wouldn't they just take up their rightful seat (by virtue of their shareholding)
And finally, assuming the Board implements the decision they made in August 2020, the whole Board will be up for re-election. Try to imagine what it would take for BHP to organise a coup of that magnitude and please give me ANY example where that has happened in corporate history?
Even then, they would then have to call an EGM and put up their own candidates.
But why on earth go to all that trouble when all they have to do is table a knockout bid and take us out lock, stock and barrel, including the entire Board of Directors.
So in conclusion I understand that some people have this BHP bogey man fear and to be clear I have never supported BHP but I do see the sense of a BHP JV for Alpala on our terms to unlock and monetise the rest of the portfolio...
But some of the theories being put forward are fantasy land...
Frankly I would be much more concerned if Nick sold out to...say the Chinese...after all, he brought them in through the front door...
Seasons greetings