RE: Too Expensive4 Oct 2022 10:27
BILLBURSIO - fair enough. We all want different things from our investments and will have a different take on them accordingly. I agree P/Es can be a useful guide. But they're largely backward-looking, as any forward P/Es are based on future profit estimates. Whilst I fully expect HAT's P/E to drop significantly over the next 12 months, you perhaps do not. 2020 was really BEFORE HAT started showing its full potential in a slowing economy. So of course the metrics looked better then, as many investors either hadn't spotted where it was heading or didn't believe it would get there. Plus we were in lockdowns for a chunk of that time, when all bets were off. I was lucky enough to anticipate correctly with this share (it doesn't happen often!), buying throughout the FCA investigation period at around £3, again at £2.50 & again just below £2. HAT's been paying me a decent yield ever since, as well as generating a strong capital return to date (though this can really only be judged when I come to sell). Personally, I think this share's got another year or so's growth in it and will temporarily re-rate above £5 at some point during that time. But that's just my hunch and I could well be wrong. As your 2020/22 buy/sale demonstrates, timing is everything with HAT. This is not a share to tuck away & forget. The difference between making 20%-30% and >100% is vast in anyone's language. DA_MATSER - Yes the dilution will have a dividend impact. But that potentially ignores what HAT does with the extra money raised. If it increases its pledge book & store estate prudently using the proceeds, this should lead to higher sales & profits. Which in turn should a) boost the share price and b) allow it to increase dividends further. The spread on this share can be wide, but it also fluctuates. So again, timing can make a significant difference. And as the 3 year figures on the chart link below show, by buying in Oct 20 and selling mid-Sept 22, you’d have made around 114% excluding dividends. Even with a 3% spread, that's a great return! hTTps://www.hl.co.uk/shares/shares-search-results/h/h-and-t-group-ord-gbp0.05