RE: Woodsmith27 Mar 2026 18:49
SaintBaklava - many thanks for your reply which appears very genuine to me!
Please accept my apologies if you detected a whiff of scepticism - probably more than 3000 of my posts on LSE have been replies to Trolls and historically if I see a new poster with 18 posts which all seem, IMO a tad negative, I hope I can be forgiven for flirting with the thought that if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck …….LOL!
As you will gather from the above I enjoy a bit of banter with trolls and I’ve done it myself so I know it’s testing but when done well it can be devastatingly effective. Quite often I’ve learned much from trolls and it sometimes has caused me to re evaluate my position.
Getting back to Woodsmith I prefer to take a pragmatic view and look forward to the future, pretty much forgetting about the 5bn already in the hole when evaluating whether to spend another 5bn to achieve a finished project which could produce for many decades. Obviously if Mitsubishi take say 25% and pay 2.5 bn that would be great - it’s not cast in stone what % they will take and it’s also not stated, for me to see, that their possible 25% share would cost 2.5bn or they may get better terms. IMO AAL won’t roll over too much on the deal because AAL can, at a push, wave goodbye to a bad deal - I suggest they would have already pretty much agreed terms and wouldn’t have gone public without a good understanding, but until AAL bank cash and dot i’s and cross t’s it’s a little up in the air.
I am really pleased you have reacted positively to the Mitsubishi involvement, particularly with your experience in the field and your knowledge of end user markets.
AAL are a mega company and the BOD are paid to strategise the business for the future. They don’t know for sure what price per ton they will get for POLY 4 in the future but I suspect they’ve run a model with increasing population and fertiliser demand by farmers, particularly those wanting a “ green “ product. This is a long term punt that diversifies company income stream for the future and I applaud it. Copper’s been great for AAL but things can change as we saw with Platinum where volte face on EVs sent price from the doldrums to stratosphere in double quick time.
Onwards and Upwards!