RE: LITHIUM FIRE9 Jan 2024 13:56
I think the EV initiative will wither on the vine. There are too many issues with EVs
INCREASED CARBON EMISSIONS: over it's life time an EV with decent range (ie battery) will be responsible for MORE NOT LESS carbon emissions than an ICE. Considerably more 'stuff' needs to be mined, refined, processed and manufactured to create an EV. Moreover on the road there may be zero emissions but these have probably just been moved down the road to the nearest power station (unless it is a solar/wind farm etc - unlikely).
RANGE ANXIETY: used for short repeated journeys an EV would be a expensively useful second car option. The problems arise when touring / on long distance trips. Leaving aside that the infrastructure more or less doesn't exist, even where it does it is a highly unsatisfactory experience. It takes a long time to charge a battery. If someone gets to a station before you it will be an even longer wait. If there are multiple stations the available load is probably reduced and shared amongst the stations. To interact with the station you may well have to 'download an App' and register details with the service provider.
TYRES: EV batteries are extremely heavy (typically 300->400kg). Electric motors are more powerful than their ICE equivalents. Put the two things together an you have a vehicle that will chew through expensive tyres.
FIRE HAZARD EV batteries are a massive fire hazard. Considerable effort is taken to mitigate the risks but it is always there.
INSURANCE: Any damage that might compromise a battery will require an extremely expensive battery replacement. Minor shunts can turn into total write offβs (a replacement battery would cost more than the residual value of the car). Further EVs are much heavier with power to match so any collisions will be more serious (there probably needs to be a review of road crash standards). Consequently insurance costs for EV's are significantly higher.
DEPRECIATION: with increasing 'flying hours' it is becoming clear that EV hype does not match reality. Unfortunately early adopters are finding that their very expensive purchases have very poor residual values.
RAW MATERIALS: current mining capacity is incapable of delivering enough raw materials to deliver 'GEN 1' of an EV fleet, never mind the massive upgrade to power generation and distribution infrastructure that would be required to make it work. There pretty much is a moratorium on opening mines world wide. This is incompatible with 'we need more copper, lithium, cobalt, graphite etc for EV batteries'. Where mining does occur it tends to be in the last places where it should occur eg the DRC. Little or no thought seems to have been given to what will happen with the large pile of toxic 'GEN 1' batteries when they are thrown on the scrap heap.
THE CAR OWNS YOU AS MUCH AS YOU OWN IT: An EV typically comes with lots of 'smarts' and may well require that you interact with it though an 'App'. It will have lots of opinions about