RE: IMF says UK faces five more years of high interest rates11 Oct 2023 06:50
I.Armani. Maths not your strong point then?
Your figures are total nonsense. Of course, there are many who take out more than they put in, but you cannot possibly deduce how many from the quoted statistics.
From the numbers you quote, it is impossible to calculate what % take out more than they put in. It obviously won't be the case in practice but it is perfectly possible that all could be making a positive contribution.
Let's look at some notional numbers.
Imagine a 100 households contributing a total of £100,000, an average of £1000 each.
50% of households pay 78% totalling £78,000 or an average of £1560 each.
50% of households pay 22% totalling £22,000 or an average of £440 each.
So, in theory, all could contribute something.
In this notional scenario, on average the richest 50% woukd pay about three and a half times the poorest.
You could multiply all the above numbers by any factor you like to give a more realistic average tax contribution but the ratio would still be the same.
In the real world the top few % would be paying much more and the bottom would be taking out more than they put in, but I repeat you can't say that from the quoted numbers.
I am not making any political statement about the fairness of the tax system, just on the lack of logic in your deduction.