RE: Cineplex8 Aug 2022 18:26
I think their fair value of McBride is probably accurate, or at least realistic. No major debt, £70m cash in the bank - which is 3x the company's market cap. Transient problems that has resulted in the stock being hammered - specifically, rising costs (as with all businesses right now) and supply chain issues (specifically lack of HGV drivers). These issues have hit the business hard but the company should come out the other side okay considering it's in good shape with low debt. As for Cineworld, I'm not sure SWS take into account the court case and the consequences of potentially having to pay that huge £720m fine? I'm not sure they take into account the huge debt? I'd question if their analysis of Cineworld is even upto date - I generally think they're a pretty good site and worth reading, although sometimes I do think they get it wrong, or at least seem to have fair value way off the mark. In the case of McBride, I think their assessment is probably realistic. And no, I'm not a holder as I stated recently on the McBride board. So I don't benefit even if I was 'ramping'. I might buy after their September update if it reads positive - but not before. In the case of Cineworld, sure they could be right - it's just that I don't agree with them. If they win the appeal, as I've already said, my views here would turn more bullish - but I still don't think they will win the appeal. They've already lost the case once - it's currently 1-0 to Cineplex and I suspect it'll be 2-0 shortly.p