RE: RSA v Aviva11 Nov 2013 13:38
Twonko you may be right and your comparison is food for thought. If your buying "now" though, do you go for one that is 35% more? If it wasn't for all the bad news, noise, fear and greed you would never buy on dips, cos dips by their very nature imply bad times. Once the dust has settled (or issues forgotten) things tend to pick up. Yes its a risk.
There are a lot of good companies, some better than this but they are trading at a premium. This dog could fall further and the management are not on the ball at the moment but there comes a point when it becomes a massive bargain if it keep falling. It could be a value trap of course. Have you sold your RSA today and swapped for Aviva?
I'm not saying your wrong, from here on, you might be repeating your "Aviva has gained 35% and RSA has dropped 2%." again next year.