Share Buyback25 Sep 2023 10:58
Hi All
The previous buyback was pretty bad. Announced in September 2022 to expire in June 2023, a maximum of 85m shares was to be bought, the actual number ended up being only 7.9m Shares, and petered out last October. (1)
The most recent buyback has been so far hopeless. Announced late in June and so far has only involved 1.1m shares. (2)
The monthly volume is about 25m, so why isn't the company buying a minimum or 5m shares a month ?
Should we retail investors assume that they expect the share price to go lower ? Or that they are not really interested in a buyback other than to promote retail investor sentiment ?
Sentiment is not exactly great out in the fickle world of investment as exemplified by the risk analysis of Simply Wall St. "Earnings are forecast to decline by an average of 79.9% per year for the next 3 years" (3), despite their fair value being much higher as it is also in recent broker reports, their own presentation, and of course the usual kind of negative postings and arguments on the share discussion boards that usually go along with a price decline.
Does DEC have to pay tax on the buybacks ?
(4) reading the rules it's not clear but I assume DEC does not have to pay tax. Even at 1% this would still be worth it surely ? Buy what about if it's raised to 4% ?
"Diversified Energy Insiders Placed Bullish Bets Worth US$449k". (5) This is a bullish headline.
(1)(Exact figure from "Transaction in Own Shares" RNS releases 850,836,129 - 842,965,753)
(2)(Exact figure from "Transaction in Own Shares" RNS releases 971,309,753 - 970,196,699)
(3) "Earnings are forecast to decline by an average of 79.9% per year for the next 3 years"
https://simplywall.st/stocks/gb/energy/lse-dec/diversified-energy-shares
(4) https://www.bakerbotts.com/thought-leadership/publications/2022/september/new-1-excise-tax-on-stock-buybacks-by-publicly-traded-corporations
A “covered corporation” generally is a domestic corporation the stock of which is traded on an established securities market (within the meaning of IRC Section 7704(b)(1)).
Repurchases include not only stock acquisitions by the covered corporation itself, but also stock acquisitions by “specified affiliates” of the covered corporation. A “specified affiliate” includes any corporation more than 50% of whose stock is owned (by vote or value), or any partnership more than 50% of the capital or profits interests of which is held, directly or indirectly by the covered corporation.
Similar rules would apply to repurchases of stock (i) of a publicly-traded foreign corporation by certain specified affiliates of such foreign corporation and (ii) by certain foreign corporations that have engaged in material acquisitions of U.S. businesses on or after September 20, 2021 and are treated as “surrogate foreign corporations” under the U.S. “anti-inversion” rules or their specified affiliates.
(5) https://uk.style.yahoo.com/diversified-energy-insiders-placed-bull