RE: There's no easy answer.....18 Mar 2023 23:10
Buy Aviva, L&G and rivals as 'no such things as a run on an insurer' - analysts
15:09 Thu 16 Mar 2023
Oliver Haill
View
Aviva PLC
LSE:AV.
Aviva PLC -
"Insurers are not banks" and the share price falls in Aviva PLC (LSE:AV.), Just Group PLC (LSE:JUST), Legal & General Group PLC (LSE:LGEN), M&G PLC (LSE:MNG) and Phoenix Group Holdings PLC (LSE:PHNX) following the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SBC) are "a buying opportunity", according to analysts at RBC.
Since the collapse of SVB, this group of UK annuity writers has seen particularly large share price falls, in sync with those in the banking sector.
The European insurance sector fell 10% since the close last Thursday, RBC noted.
The analysts said "insurers and banks are fundamentally different" and the circumstances that sparked the SVB's collapse "simply could not occur at an insurer".
"We see the reduction in share prices as a buying opportunity and we highlight the UK annuity writers as attractive at current valuation levels, with all outperforming earnings expectations at FY22 results."
RBC reckons the annuity writers "should benefit from the rapid acceleration in the bulk annuity opportunity, a slowdown in future longevity improvements, and Solvency II reform".
As banks only keep a small proportion of their assets as cash, bank runs can start from mere doubts that a bank may be in trouble, which leads to customers withdrawing their money.
The analysts added that "there is no such thing as a run on an insurer", noting that insurers provide protection against risk, so customers pay in premiums, which insurers put into reserves.
The analysts stressed that the basis of insurance is about sharing risk, so customers who claim are subsidised by those who do not, whereas for banks a customer can choose to withdraw their deposit at any time.
With annuities, the analysts noted, the insurer "knows exactly what it needs to pay out" from week to week, which are recorded as its liabilities.
"The only thing that can go wrong is if the annuitants live too long (and this risk is currently going the other way). Even if that were to happen, it is not a near term risk.
"To meet these liabilities, the insurer invests in a portfolio of assets which would provide the right amount of cash flow at the right time. The only thing that could go wrong here is if one of the assets defaults.
"Assets and liabilities are exactly matched (by duration, by currency, by inflation, and by interest rates) and little can impact either. To provide a safety net, insurers are required to hold very large capital buffers, which are at all-time highs.
"While bank customers can choose to withdraw their deposits there is no ability for an annuitant to withdraw."