The missing facts for this decision....plant capacity2 Apr 2024 16:31
My view is we don't have all the jigsaw pieces of this decision as yet and the circumstances will be much clearer at the date of the end of year announcement (mid April) together with the important wider pipeline outlook perspectives we know are coming.
Like you all my heart sank a little this morning when hearing the news. However, after more thought I believe there is a very good and sensible business reason for ITX to turn away these weakly profitable or marginally loss making revenues due to future limited manufacturing capacity (ie. our critical profit limiting resource maybe coming as early as 2025). Plant capacity is our current scare resource in the next 12 to 18 months before we can commission a duplicate facility in Europe and transfer all that is needed and train new staff. Based on my knowledge of business economics you always profit maximise based on your product portfolio and the principal limited resource constraint. For us it's our physical plant capacity and to a certain degree plant operator workforce yet to be hired. So if I am right, this unusual decision is linked heavily to other portfolio contract constraints that means its perfect sense to turn away some 'skimmed milk' today for better tasting 'double cream' during later 2024 or early 2025. If we maintained status quo supply we may find ourselves turning away or significantly delaying a much better profit generation contract. From this decision there is alot going on behind the scenes in my opinion that never gets public viewing. If there are more mgt. sounds made about the European facility in the next few weeks, I believe I am correct and the SP will rebound accordingly. As for the quantum of the SP drop. Its currently non intuitive given the value of each major diversification channel incl. Superabsorbants, paints and leather which must each represent a minimum of say USD10m of risk adjusted value given commercial/ technical progress to date. My thinking these should represent approx 50% of the ITX enterprise value right now after deducting the free cash of say USD 6m (working capital / capex adjusted excess). So work out the numbers as they don't stack up at the moment. Once more news flows I think we will get the bigger picture context. Plant constraint could be the key missing decision perspective. (but as ever DYOR).