Edison6 Feb 2021 19:02
Skindle, I am not sure if you are correct with the amount Frasers have sold and that aside, I wouldn’t read anything into what they have sold. They still have the largest say in our future direction.
I would expect the Board to provide an update soon as it has now been 2 months since the announcement of the full strategic review and would like commentary beyond it just being ongoing.
In the meantime, below is Edison’s opinion on the SP back at 19.12.20. With everything that has changed since, a fair value north of £6 is not unreasonable by any measure. Not comparing an apple with an apple but the recent valuation ascribed to Moonpig underscores this and suggests there should be strong interest in STU as a highly profitable online retailer openly seeking a new owner in an environment of cash rich deal makers keen to do business.
Studio benefiting from the shift to digital
The first six months of the financial year are somewhat seasonally less important (H119 was c 43% of FY19 revenue) for the Studio (Product and Financial Services) division. In total, the division’s revenue was broadly flat at +0.3%, gross profit improved by 6% and adjusted operating profit increases by 1.1%. The company does not chase sales ahead of the peak trading period in Q3, in which, to date, it has traded strongly, with 10% Product revenue growth, underpinning our broadly unchanged assumption of 7% revenue growth for FY20. The company has highlighted record numbers of customers, single-day online sessions and daily dispatches, implying strong customer acceptance for the move to digital.
Planned disposal of Education
The planned disposal of Education to a competitor, YPO, for gross consideration of £50m (10.3x adjusted EBITDA in FY19), represents the final disposal in the transition to being a digital-first, value-focused retailer. Completion is expected in 2020 and the transaction is subject to clearance by the Competition and Markets Authority. Net proceeds are likely to be £35m, some of which may be invested in warehousing infrastructure. The transformation over the last two years, with changes to products, solutions, pricing and controlling of costs, is feeding through to improved profitability for Education: H120 revenue -1.4% and adjusted operating profit +64%, derived from greater volume of own brand and online sales at higher margin.
Valuation: Well supported by DCF valuation of 450p
Our revenue forecasts are relatively unchanged, but our PBT estimate for FY20 has increased by 2% to reflect the improved gross margin performance in H120. Our DCF-based valuation increases to 450p from 423p, representing a premium of 90% to the current share price.