CANTOR - BUY 315p16 Jan 2024 08:25
Molten Ventures is a listed VC fund specialising in early-stage investments with a focus on emerging technologies. Historical investments have included UiPath, Trustpilot and TransferWise. Since IPO, Molten has compounded NAV at 15% annually and generated an average IRR of 30% on the gross portfolio. This strong track record is not reflected in its shares, which are trading at a c70% discount to NAV, the highest in the company's history. The discount is driven by the market's fear over Molten's debt and liquidity position, despite the company having several levers at its disposal to address this. In addition, we believe the market has failed to realise the downside protection offered by Molten's superior position on the cap table as a preferential shareholder in 97% of its investments. We initiate with an Overweight rating and price target of 315p.
Fears of equity raise overblown. Molten has already raised c£57m in equity in late 2023, and we believe it can resolve the liquidity issue with its banks and avoid issuing additional equity and diluting shareholders. Management has also commented that it believes realisations of c20% of the existing portfolio are possible in the next 12 months. This would potentially result in the discount narrowing to c50% of NAV, resulting in c85% upside for the shares. While risks still exist, we believe they are already priced into the substantial discount.
Downside protection against permanent capital impairment. Around 97% of Molten's investments are through preference shares, which protect against a permanent impairment of capital. This essentially means that in order for one of these investments to be loss-making, it would have to trade at an amount below the capital initially invested. We view this as unlikely since the average size of its core portfolio is just c£18m versus an average fair value of c£48m, implying valuations would need to fall >50%.
Well-funded portfolio with strong underlying growth and catalysts. Molten's underlying portfolio growth remains strong and the company expects revenues to expand 50% over the next 12 months. The portfolio companies are also well funded, with 80% having a cash runway to at least September 2024. Additionally, Molten's largest holding, Thought Machine, is growing at >50% and media reports have speculated on a potential IPO this year or in 2025; we believe this would unlock significant value for shareholders.
Valuation. Molten is one of the cheapest stocks in our VC coverage, trading at c70% discount to NAV. We believe this valuation is unsustainable given the number of opportunities Molten has to extract value from its existing portfolio. We value Molten using a blended ROI valuation and a peers-based EV/sales multiple to reach our price target of 315p.
Catalysts. Share price catalysts could come from a resolution to the liquidity issue, better-than-expected realisations from the existing portfolio and news of a substantial exit, such as Thought Mac