So here we are27 Nov 2021 09:05
Well I called that badly wrong.Under company guidance I assumed a $500m raise and a single cornerstone.Hence mathematically believed the cornerstone would have to pay a premium to stay under 30%.I had just seen a 15% premium paid by Piedmont for a chunk of Ironridge-premiums can and do happen.We end up with $630m and 2 cornerstones.I do not blame management-with hindsight I am sure the banks had them under the cosh re a huge equity contingency and then Orion and La Mancha put them in a headlock.However,I do think management could have given us some indication of the upscaling of the deal size-they chose not to and the market (and me) got caught by surprise.It is of no surprise at all then that the price is now 6.5p-I assume management are not surprised by this either-they must have realised this was going to happen.
So the upsize I understand and do not blame management-but they could have limited damage by warning the market-that was poor judgement.What does annoy me and I note Rosy Lee also expressed surprise is the CLNs.I do not have a problem with CLNs per se,but the terms here are penal to existing holders-11.5% interest plus conversion at 8.75p (they were taking higher than this in February).6/7% interest and conversion at 12p would have been more palatable.
Now the option package-I am a big supporter of using options to incentivise management, but under the right terms.Let's award them on achievement of challenging milestones and certain share price levels been achieved-otherwise they become giveaways not incentives.
On the share consolidation-great news.While we are at it lets also uplift to the FTSE and appoint a decent global broker.BMO is good in Canada,Peel Hunt is a Tier 2 traditional UK broker.The February placing was disaster (although I agreed with the logic) and by the short that has just been reported it seems that the placing brokers were once again allowed to get away with a pretty shoddy book.Please appoint someone like Jefferies who have very strong UK,European and USA distribution and excellent M&A credentials-then we might start getting the like of Blackrock and Fidelity onto the register.I would bet a lot of money the places this time around are again a bunch of second tier institutions and hedge funds.
I added more on Thursday and am now substantially into 8 figures shares, but like others am now expecting slower appreciation and less upside.HZM is now tucked away for 5 years (or takeover) and new money will go into ALL and ACP who have greater and quicker upside.HZM is for retirement.