Record Interim Profitability3 Mar 2021 13:30
Pan African Resources’ (PAF) interim results to end-December 2020 were reported in the context of already known production and were well within the range indicated by its JSE paragraph 3.4(b) announcement of 8 February.
EPS and HEPS almost doubled in the period to 2.11c/share, albeit this included an (effectively) exceptional loss from the last of PAF’s hedge programme, which if excluded would have increased EPS and HEPS to (we estimate) 2.46c/share (see Exhibit 2).
Moreover, this result was achieved despite a 21.7 percentage point increase in the effective tax rate as a result of a material deferred tax charge for the first time, which if excluded would have increased normalised HEPS still further, to 2.93c/share.
Assuming a similar performance in H221 would imply a normalised P/E ratio for PAF of just 5.7x in FY21, well below the average of its peers (see Exhibit 6).
Underground grades back to where they belong
Particularly notable within the detail of the results were the head grade mined from underground operations at Barberton, which we estimate to have been 11.25g/t (cf the 8.79g/t that we estimated in H220 – a 28.0% increase) and the head grade recorded at the BTRP and Elikhulu, which were also both above our expectations, albeit these were partially offset by early teething problems at the Evander 8 Shaft Pillar project (eg a ventilation shaft lining fracture), which have now been rectified. Subject to the unexpected therefore and given that it produced 98.4koz in H121, we regard it as extremely unlikely that PAF will fail to achieve its FY21 production target of 190koz for the current year (see Exhibit 1).
Valuation: 38.41–43.43c (27.62–31.23p) per share
Since our last major note on PAF, the rand has appreciated by 12.4% relative to the US dollar, from ZAR16.5113/US$ to ZAR14.4578/US$, which has contributed to an albeit lesser 5.7% reduction in our valuation of the company to 38.19c (27.46p) based on its four currently producing assets plus Egoli. To this must then be added the value of c 19.2m underground Witwatersrand ounces, which we estimate could lie anywhere in the range of 0.22–5.24c per share, plus PAF's other assets to take the total to 38.41–43.43c/share. As an alternative means of valuation, if PAF’s historical average price to normalised EPS ratio of 9.1x in the period FY10–20 is applied to our FY21 and FY22 forecasts, then it implies a share price of 27.6p in FY21 followed by 35.4p in FY22. On the basis of its FY20 dividend and our forecast FY21e dividend, it is among the top 20 yielding precious metals companies globally. In the meantime, investors can buy the shares on a resource multiple of only US$13.86/oz and a reserve multiple of only US$47.79/oz.
https://www.edisongroup.com/publication/record-interim-profitability/28966