RE: HoldingsToday 14:55
Mr Thistle,
Your Link is to the National Security Register (NRR) and it doesn't really concern M&A activity. If you read the Intro it says this:
These are not the only risks facing the UK. The NRR focuses on ‘acute’
risks, which are discrete events requiring an emergency response. In
addition, the UK faces a range of serious ‘chronic’ risks, which are
long-term challenges that gradually erode our economy, community,
way of life, and/or national security.
I think it is arguable that the takeover of an Iconic National Infrastructure Asset like the Royal Mail merits a review under all 4 of the 'chronic' risks listed above, details of which are not included in the NRR document that you linked.
The intro also goes on to refer to the 'Integrated Review Refresh' released in 2023 which sets out the the Govt's new process for identifying and assessing these 'chronic' risks - subtitled: 'Responding to a more contested and volatile world'. A reasonable argument to suggest that any decision reached in 2022 may not still hold when revisited in similar circumstances in 2024.
For a footnote here's why I think that the Bid poses 'chronic' risk:
1. Erode our economy - the transfer of ownership into foreign hands could be seen as doing this. Loss of FTSE listing, Profits due to foreign entity etc
2. Community - here I feel strongly, I know my Postie, he's been coming for years, and the one before that. I trust him, as do many people, and he is part of our community. Unlike the countless delivery drivers who work for all of the other delivery companies, none of whom we ever see twice. I fear that this would change if the Royal mail becomes just another commercial delivery business - they would inevitably screw their employees on pay and benefits to drive down costs and eventually the staff turnover would result in just more strangers coming to the door.
3. Way of life - pretty much the same argument as above. But also the universal service obligation - which surely any bidder will promise to do the right thing but we all know Corporate Promises are entirely worthless. Admittedly the USO will change whatever happens but I don't like to think that a bidder will get the inevitable uplift in value when that happens when it does.
4. National security - well, I get my passport, driving licence, HMRC letters, local Govt corresspondance amongst other things delivered by the Royal mail. They also have a pretty detailed dataset of the name and address of every single individual in the country and who is sending them stuff. I could go on...