RE: IC article31 Aug 2022 23:13
Sandfire has announced positive news flow, too. Earlier this week, the Australian group released a positive definitive feasibility study for an expanded 5.2m tonnes per year mining operation that combines Sandfire’s T3 Copper-Silver and A4 projects at its Motheo Copper Mine in Botswana. The economics are compelling even allowing for a 9.5 per cent upward revision in the projects capital’s costs. That’s because Sandfire estimates an all-in sustaining cost (AISC) of US$1.79 per pound of copper, or half the current spot price, which produces a net present value of $548mn (7 per cent discount rate) over a 10-year mine life with peak annual production of 55,000 tonnes of copper-in-concentrate. Sandfire has already invested almost half of the US$397mn of the project’s development costs, and has secured $140mn of project debt finance facilities with a syndicate of banks.
Metal Tiger’s holding in Sandfire aside, the company holds a 2 per cent net smelter royalty (NSR) on the A4 project, which has been conservatively valued at £9.7mn (5.7p a share) in its accounts, and a capped NSR over the T3 project (carrying value of £1.3mn). Royalties from A4 could be worth $8.9mn (£7.7mn) a year to Metal Tiger (at an annual production rate of 3.2mn tonnes and a copper price of $9,000 per tonne – consensus forecasts on Bloomberg for period of production), highlighting the potential for a massive uplift in the value of this investment. Moreover, Metal Tiger has several other potential copper targets owned by Sandfire in Botswana that are subject to uncapped NSRs.
Although Metal Tiger’s share price has rallied 22 per cent since I last highlighted the glaring valuation anomaly (‘Exploiting a valuation disconnect’, 20 June 2022), and is 48 per cent above the entry point in my 2020 Bargain Shares Portfolio, it is still trading around 20 per cent below my spot NAV estimates. That’s a harsh valuation. Buy.