RE: Tender Offer17 Feb 2024 12:29
First of all it matter little what PIs do, it is the IIs which are important. I think this is aimed at IIs who want to reduce their position but do not want to dump a lot of shares on the market harming them by bring the price down of the rest of their investment.
There is no way posting to (in effect) an anonymous group of people advising them to act as a team will change anything, every person will make up their own minds based on their views and circumstance. It is highly unlikely many people will go along with a plan where they take a loss (even if it small) for the so called team and then have all the admin of dealing with CT etc.
For me it is simple, I will take the dividend and put it to good use elsewhere (I guess I am a selfish non team player), DEC was by far my largest investment a few months back but has dropped down the list due to SP crash. I am deep enough into losses here already and don’t want to risk more or take more loses of my own making and very disappointed with the BBs so far. If there are no other significant changes and DEC decides to go on a concerted BB plan I will consider adding some more.
For me in a SIPP I will lose if I take the tender offer, if in an ISA with WHT at 15% again it makes no sense to take the offer (unless being a team player means more to you avoiding more losses). There has been a lot of discussion about whether it is worth taking up the offer, for most no, however there may be a few where it works out if not in SIPP or ISA. There are so many individual factors, WHT tax rate (depending on broker), dividend tax rate, CGT position, even if resident outside of UK etc.
The offer will turn dividend to CG, 5% on top of your current gain loss if HMRC don’t think it is tax avoidance, however there is the possibility you could end up in a bun fight with HMRC. Some may wish to take a CT loss which can be used against other gains (10% or 20% depending on tax bracket), there are so many individual factors to give a general answer.
Still can’t understand why DEC do not do a dividend script issue, a lot who take up the script offer will keep the shares and money save in the dividend can buy back shares which will be cancelled so at worst a neutral affect but in reality more shares in the long term holder’s hands and less for shorting/day traders.