RE: The useless government of all time15 Nov 2025 09:23
Headder
You’re again mixing several unrelated issues and drawing conclusions that don’t hold up.
Your experience on a handful of sites doesn’t invalidate the broader data on labour shortages, skill gaps, or the changing composition of the construction workforce. The UK has relied on migrant labour — particularly post-2008 — to keep major infrastructure and housing projects deliverable at all. That’s not “chest beating”; it’s recognising industry realities that employers themselves have repeatedly stated.
On the wider claims about education, stagnant growth, and generational welfare dependency: those problems are structural, not demographic. They stem from decades of uneven regional investment, weak productivity gains, mismatched university pathways, and the absence of coherent industrial strategy. Blaming immigrants for issues rooted in policy, training, and economic design only distracts from the actual levers that need pulling.
If anything, the construction sector demonstrates the opposite of your point: when the UK doesn’t train enough domestic labour or incentivise mobility, the economy turns to migrant workers to fill the gap — and projects continue that would otherwise stall.
So yes, immigration has helped. What hasn’t helped is the tendency to bundle economic, educational, and social failures into one catch-all narrative instead of addressing the underlying causes.