RE: Good Morning All20 Jun 2024 10:25
"Why do PIs focus obsessively on the super high dividend yield of these UK insurers - Phnx and Lgen in particular - when a cursory glance shows that Total Returns have been negative over a multi year period, during which time even an indexed fund would have been a better choice?"
By and large, I don't think they do. Although as primarily income investors they are naturally going to be focused on the income the shares provide. However, the impact over the short term is likely being discounted because they are planning to hold for a very long-term during which they believe the fluctuation in share prices will either have little impact, balance out or improve in favour of the investor (after all past performance is not a guarantee as to how investments will perform in the future). With a solid, growing company, throwing off lots of cash to shareholders the big risk for an investor from the falling share price is probably the risk of a forced sale capitalising those paper losses. On the other hand Falling share prices may provide an opportunity to buy more shares at a level you believe offers value.
In short, I think it is fair to say that there are a variety of reasons why insurance company share prices have been hit over the last 4-5 years and visible drivers that may (or may not!) lead to some rise in prices going forwards. Discussions around Total Return should take those both into account.