Value anomaly noticed by ft17 Dec 2020 21:06
Please use the sharing tools found via the share button at the top or side of articles. Copying articles to share with others is a breach of FT.com T&Cs and Copyright Policy. Email licensing@ft.com to buy additional rights. Subscribers may share up to 10 or 20 articles per month using the gift article service. More information can be found at https://www.ft.com/tour.
https://www.ft.com/content/91db3d6e-cfa1-450d-bee4-7fa09e5907c0
ThinkSmart is a micro-cap listed on London’s infamous Alternative Investment Market.
Valued at just £59m, the payments company reported Wednesday that it had been a good year for shareholder returns, with dividends paid out amounting to 21 per cent of the share price. Not a bad yield in today’s interest rate environment.
Yet it wasn’t the juicy cash payout that caught our eye, but another line in the RNS:
The Group also notes the trading update issued by Afterpay Ltd on 2 December 2020 where it reported that its UK division, Clearpay, delivered c. $200 million of underlying sales in November 2020, in what was a record month for Afterpay. This represented c10% of Afterpay's global underlying sales for the month, up from 7% in the 3 months to 30 September 2020.
Which got us wondering, why is this tiny company mentioning Afterpay — the A$28bn Australian payments company?
Well, flick back to its full-year results from September, and you’ll see all of the company’s profits in 2019 were driven by a 10 per cent stake in a similarly named business called ClearPay.
Here’s the relevant wording:
Profit after tax up 513% to £53.0 million (FY19 restated (1): £8.7 million) driven by £53.7 million (2) non-cash fair value gain on independent valuation of the Group's retained 10% shareholding in Clearpay Finance Ltd (“Clearpay”)
Which got us digging a little more, at which point we ran into what can only be described as a valuation conundrum. And you know how we love those.
First, some background.
The rest of Clearpay is owned by Afterpay which, like Square and Adyen, has been a beneficiary of investor hype around the digital payments space. The company’s valuation stands at a rather mind-boggling 29 times forward revenues, according to S&P Global data, and it’s share price is up a staggering 236 per cent this year.
You might be familiar with Afterpay’s business model. Like Klarna, it offers consumers the chance to purchase an item online, but defer the payment to a set date interest-free. The vendor receives the cash minus a commission straight away, with AfterPay collecting the proceeds later. Only if a consumer misses a payment do the fees begin to rack up.
So where does ThinkSmart come in? Well in August 2018 it sold 90 per cent of Clearpay to Afterpay for around A$19m in stock, payable in two tranches.
As part of the deal, Afterpay has the right to purchase the remaining 10 per cent Clearpay stake in 2023 at a price agreed at the time of sale between the two parties.
If Afterpay doesn’t